Why Some Artists Avoid Black & White in Watercolors?

Black & White Tubes

Why Some Artists Avoid Black in Watercolors:

1. It Flattens the Painting

Black can make areas look dull or lifeless because it lacks the color complexity you get from mixing your own darks.

2. It Muddies Other Colors

When you mix black with bright colors, the result can look muddy or “dirty” instead of vibrant.

3. You Can Mix Better Darks

Experienced artists often mix deep colors using complementary colors (like blue + orange or red + green) to create rich, glowing shadows that still feel colorful.

4. Payne’s Gray Is a Better Option

Many artists use Payne’s Gray, a bluish-gray alternative, for dark areas. It’s softer and blends better with other watercolor tones.


Why Some Artists Avoid White in Watercolors:

1. Watercolor Is Transparent by Nature

Watercolor shines because of its luminosity—light reflects through transparent layers of paint and bounces off the white paper underneath.

2. White Paint Looks Chalky

When you add white paint, it sits on top of the paper and makes colors look opaque and flat, which defeats the natural glow of watercolor.

3. Highlights Should Come from the Paper

Skilled watercolorists plan ahead and leave white areas unpainted to create highlights. It takes practice, but it keeps your painting fresh and light-filled.


When It’s Okay to Use Black or White

  • You're a beginner and still learning

  • You’re working in mixed media

  • You want a bold, graphic style

  • You're painting on colored or toned paper

  • You're combining watercolor with gouache